
Anyone who knows me knows that I'm a bleeding-heart liberal to the core. I have been since I was a child. Maybe it started when I began spending summers living at the home of my childhood best friend, whose whole family was pacifist and vegetarian, or when, at the tender age of nine, I was told by the priest at my Catholic school that no matter how hard I worked, I could never become a priest myself. Maybe it started the first time I nicked myself shaving my legs as a teenager and said, "I shouldn't have to do this." Who knows. My point is, it started early.
But even for all that -- no, BECAUSE of all that -- I consider myself to be patriotic, maybe even extremely so. I'm using the definition of patriotism that people used hundreds of years ago, the one described in phrases like "Dissent is patriotic." Therefore, journalism is patriotic. Being "diverse" in some (preferably freaky) way is patriotic too. And holding a sign or passing out fliers that someone doesn't like is --contrary to popular belief -- patriotic.
So where do we draw the line?
Here.
When a 21-year-old in North Carolina guy is sending Al Qaeda signals on YouTube, the Western world is too free.
It's sad, too, because I AGREE that Americans are embarrassing ourselves on the world stage in a million ways right now. But the solution to that is not for us to continue laissez-faire-ing to the point that young people with fire in their bellies sympathize with -- and be wooed away by -- groups like Al Qaeda. That's exactly when and why kids are bad: when you don't give them any discipline, they have to push the envelope until they find something that will elicit negative feedback or someone else who will give it to them.
Now, I'm not advocating censorship (well, not quite); when these kids give us a clue as to where they are and what they're doing, that makes it a hell of a lot easier to take them out of the game (but once they have served that purpose, the videos should be taken down). What I AM advocating is the following things (not to fight Al Qaeda, but to prevent our own children from BECOMING Al Qaeda):
1.) Better historical and socio-political education at every age
2.) Every kid should have to go abroad for six months before the age of 18 to a country that has nothing to do with their family, their religion or their other interests
3.) Attending multiple kinds of religious services -- including a gathering of atheists -- should be part of a public education
4.) When they get to school, kids should be handed a newspaper (well, a monitor and mouse) every morning for half an hour and quizzed at the end of that half-hour
5.) Kids should be taught that diversity is something to be desired, not shunned
6.) Poverty and no health insurance should be considered unacceptable states for any American child. Poverty breeds resentment of authority -- and rightfully so
Am I really that naive? Do I really believe that education and participation prevent nonsense like this? Well, yeah.
Photo by Michael Moss/New York Times.
Thanks, man.